A few weeks ago, I had a
conversation with some fellow TV writers. Well, I say a conversation; it was
more a cathartic expulsion of bile and frustration. But then don’t all
conversations between writers ultimately end up that way?
Anyway, the topic
under discussion was “things that TV Development Producers say”. Or
specifically, “things that Development Producers say that make you wish BBC
& ITV buildings had functioning windows so that you could throw yourself
out of them”. As I said, it was quite a cathartic discussion.
Many of the producer quotes were
greeted with howls of painful recognition. We’d all heard them in meeting after
meeting. Those little clichés or go-to questions that they trot out in
every meeting with every writer. So much so, that they are now a trigger for involuntary
violent fantasies. But were we being fair? Do the producers even realise that they’re
doing it? Perhaps they have no idea that we’ve heard all their little sound bites
before?
So, I’ve decide to give our
colleagues the benefit of the doubt, but offer this as a friendly guide to
things you shouldn’t say in development meetings. Especially if your windows
are open.
I also provide a little guidance
on how a writer should/should not react to these pearls of wisdom.
1. If you could sum this idea in one line…
What You Shouldn’t Say
If I could sum up my idea in one
line I wouldn’t need to write a script? Why must everything be boiled down to
the small paragraph that will appear in the Radio Times? It strikes me that if
you can’t grasp a concept that requires more than ten words you’re in the wrong
job.
What You Should Say
It’s Sherlock meets Breaking Bad.
2. This is a great start/first draft.
What You Shouldn’t Say
A great start? A great fucking
start? Have you any idea how I’ve sweated over this? And do you really think I’d
send you an actual first draft? Writing this ruined my marriage, you prick. I
missed my kid’s Nativity play to get this to you.
What You Should Say
I can’t wait to take it to the
next level.
3. Why should we tell this story now?
What You Shouldn’t Say
Because I've only just had the idea. And why does it matter anyway? By the time you’ve ummed and ahhed over
it, we’ll be five years down the line. For fuck’s sake, aliens could have
invaded and UKIP could be in government by the time you make a decision and it
actually gets on the screen. And did you ask that question when you were doing
your latest reboot/literary adaptation? Or did you just ask whether the
material was out of copyright? Wow, do they actually give you a book of stupid,
pointless questions to ask?
What You Should Say
I think we can draw a lot of
parallels between the 16th century and Austerity Britain. And stories
about the human spirit are ultimately timeless.
4. We really like what you’ve got here, but have you considered…
What You Shouldn’t Say
Of course I’ve considered it. I’ve
been through every permutation of this story to get to this point. I didn’t
just bash it out in an afternoon, you know? I’ve lived with this idea, working it
through my mind, drawing on everything I know and have experienced. I’ve lived
with these characters until I feel like I know every detail of their lives;
things that won’t make it to the screen but will inform everything they do and
say. I did all that before I could even consider showing this to you.
What You Should Say
That’s a really interesting idea.
5. Whose story is it?
What You Shouldn’t Say
It’s MINE! You can’t have it. You’re not
worthy!
What You Should Say
Ultimately, it’s about a flawed
and complicated protagonist. S/he’s an everyman/woman that the audience will
fall in love with.
6. I’ll know what I want when I see it.
What You Shouldn’t Say
Well, any chance you could give
us a clue what that might be? Start by telling us what you don’t want to see and we’ll go from
there. And don’t give me that shit about your likes and dislikes being
irrelevant and it being about ‘good writing’ when we all know it’s about who
bought you a drink down at the Groucho Club last week. When I’m made to throw
shit at the wall, I’d like to know there is an outside chance that some of it
might stick.
What You Should Say
Wow, it’s great to have such a
blank canvas. It’s like there are no wrong answers.
7. I gave your script to a friend/my kids/the girl who does my nails to
get a second opinion.
What Not To Say
Why? Are you incapable of doing
your job? Actually, I asked my postman what he thought of you and he called you
an unprofessional dick. The woman in the chip shop agreed. I like to get a second opinion too.
What To Say
It’s always good to see things
through a fresh pair of eyes.
But the ultimate annoying question and one that we’d all been asked….
8. But, if the main character does this will the audience like her/him?
What Not To Say
Perhaps not. Perhaps they’ll have
a strong emotional reaction to the character instead of simply liking them. I
like lots of people but I don’t want to give up an hour of my precious TV
viewing time to watch them. Did you like Tony Soprano? Walter White? Nurse Jackie? Hamlet? I
think you’re confusing liking a character with having sympathy for them,
identifying with them, rooting for them, being outraged by them. The job of the
screenwriter is to get us to feel something, not just to ‘like’ it.
What To Say
I was thinking we could cast
Martin Freeman/Suranne Jones.
So, there you have it; all
genuine things that are said repeatedly in development meetings. If you have
ever said any of those things to a writer; shame on you. But it’s not too late to
change your ways.
As ever comments are encouraged
and welcomed.